Delay In Filing Insurance Claim No Reason To Reject It, Says Supreme Court

08 Feb 2017 by NDTV staff

New Delhi: Insurance claims cannot be rejected if the reason for delay in filing it is satisfactorily explained, the Supreme Court has said while granting relief to a man who was denied the claim for his stolen vehicle.

A bench of Justices R K Agrawal and S Abdul Nazeer said that rejection of the claims on purely technical grounds in a mechanical manner will result in the "loss of confidence of policy-holders in insurance industry".

The observations came as the bench allowed the appeal of a man against the ruling of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) that insurance firms could deny the claim benefit for delay in filing it.

The apex court directed Reliance General Insurance Company to pay Rs. 8.35 lakh to the Hisar-based customer whose insured truck was stolen but his claim was rejected on the grounds of delay in filing it.

"If the reason for delay in making a claim is satisfactorily explained, such a claim cannot be rejected on the ground of delay. It is also necessary to state here that it would not be fair and reasonable to reject genuine claims which had already been verified and found to be correct by the Investigator," the bench said.

The apex court said that the Consumer Protection Act aims at providing better protection of the interest of consumers.

"It is a beneficial legislation that deserves liberal construction. This laudable object should not be forgotten while considering the claims made under the Act," it said. The court also observed that a person who has lost his vehicle may not straightaway go to the insurance company to claim compensation and would first make efforts to trace the vehicle.
 

"It is true that the owner has to intimate the insurer immediately after the theft of the vehicle. However, this condition should not bar settlement of genuine claims particularly when the delay in intimation or submission of documents is due to unavoidable circumstances.

The decision of the insurer to reject the claim has to be based on valid grounds, the apex court said.

According to the appeal filed by Om Prakash, his truck was stolen in Bhiwari in Rajasthan on March 23, 2010 but he filed the insurance claim on March 31 with the firm, as during that period, he was busy trying to trace it.

The theft was confirmed by the investigator and a claim of Rs. 7.85 lakh was approved by the corporate claims manager, it said, adding that the insurance firm denied him the amount saying he had violated a policy condition that made it mandatory to inform the firm immediately after any accidental loss or damage to the vehicle.

related articles

  • THE INDIAN RISK APPETITE

    It took the turn of the Century for the Indian subconscious to rekindle its business appetite which had helped them lead the world trade from 800 AD to 1300 AD. The spate of startups declared to the world that every Indian is born with a fire in his belly with great risk taking ability. Probably the same risk appetite keeps the average Indian believe that nothing bad can happen.

    Read More
  • Which Insurance policies should the corporates buy, a Finance manager’s guide

    It took the turn of the Century for the Indian subconscious to rekindle its business appetite which had helped them lead the world trade from 800 AD to 1300 AD. The spate of startups declared to the

    Read More
  • Take personal term plan along with group life insurance: Pankaj Razdan

    Since my employer is giving a group life insurance policy, should I (32 years old) also give a separate term plan?
    – Daksh Gangwar

    Primary objective of term insurance is to eliminate financial burdens a family might face in case of untimely death of the earning member. It is recommended to have a life insurance cover of 7-10 times of your annual income. It is also essential that you are covered until your retirement age. 

    Read More

Categories